Start with the same instruction
Write the concern once: the affected room or supply, the evidence available and the question you want answered. Identify whether the instruction is residential, commercial or involves shared equipment. A price displayed for one category should not be transferred to another without confirmation. Record the proposal date and version so a later clarification does not get compared with an earlier scope.
For each activity, use included, excluded, conditional or unclear. Copy the relevant wording and its reference. Silence is unclear; it is not inclusion. Compare access, plumbing repair, parts, testing, written findings and decorative reinstatement separately.
Worked illustration: resolve the ambiguous words
This fictional wording exercise is illustrative, not a customer quotation or a comparison of providers. Imagine receiving a proposal headed “investigation and repair support”. The table turns that phrase into questions that can be answered in writing. No price, outcome or level of service is assumed.
| Illustrative wording | Record now | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| Repair support | Unclear | Does this include the plumbing repair and materials, or a referral? |
| Access as required | Conditional | Which surfaces and access decisions are within the agreed instruction? |
| Report supplied | Included; detail unclear | Will findings, the assessed section and limitations be recorded? |
| Making good excluded | Excluded; clarify boundary | Which reinstatement tasks need a separate arrangement? |
Resolve the gaps before comparing totals
Send the unanswered questions together and retain the response with the proposal. Record who can approve a changed scope and how any revised price would be agreed. A clear comparison may reveal different deliverables rather than a better or worse provider. Exact Source’s package page supplies its current offer; this worksheet does not alter those terms.
Keep an insurer’s approval separate from a contractor’s scope. Ageas, for example, describes conditions and prior agreement for its own tracing cover. That illustrates why a contractor’s report or quotation cannot promise reimbursement under another policy. Ask your insurer about your own claim before relying on cover.
Your working record
Proposal comparison worksheet
Complete each activity for Proposal A and Proposal B, including the wording reference and any question still open.
Your entries stay in this page until you choose to copy, download or print them. They are not sent to us or saved after you leave. Avoid recording other people’s private details.